Thursday, March 1, 2012

Indus valley language and script (Ancient History)





The Indus Valley Civilization was the first major urban culture of South Asia. It reached its peak from 2600 BC to 1900 BC roughly, a period called by some archaeologists "Mature Harappan" as distinguished from the earlier Neolithic "Early Harappan" regional cultures.Spatially, it is huge, comprising of about 1000 settlements of varying sizes, and geographically includes almost all of modern Pakistan, parts of India as far east as Delhi and as far south as Bombay, and parts of Afghanistan.


The main corpus of writing dated from the Indus Civilization is in the form of some two thousand inscribed seals in good, legible conditions. (In case you don't know what seals are, they are used to make impressions on malleable material like clay.)

Although these seals and samples of Indus writing have been floating around the scholastic world for close to 70 years, little progress has been made on deciphering this elegant script. However, we should not blame scholars for their lack of progress, for there are some major impediments to decipherment:

1. Very short and brief texts. The average number of symbols on the seals is 5, and the longest is only 26.
2. The language underneath is unknown.
3. Lack of bilingual texts.

For instance, consider Champollion, who deciphered Egyptian hieroglyphs with all of these 3 important clues: there were very long Egyptian texts; he knew Coptic, a descendant of Egyptian; and the Rosetta Stone, a bilingual text between Greek and two written forms of Egyptian.

But the script isn't as bad as undecipherable. For one, even though scholars don't have long texts and bilingual texts, they can still theorize about the language underneath the writing system. There are several competing theories about the language that the Indus script represent:
  1. The language is completely unrelated to anything else, meaning an isolate. Well, this doesn't get us anywhere.
  2. The language is "Aryan" (some form of Indian-Iranian Indo-European). The historical languages spoken in Northern India and Pakistan all belong to the Indic branch of Indo-European, including Sanskrit, Hindi, Punjabi, etc., so maybe the people of the Indus valley spoke a very old Indo-European language?
The major problem with this model is the fact that horses played a very important role in all Indo-European cultures, being a people constantly on the move. "There is no escape from the fact that the horse played a central role in the Vedic and Iranian cultures..." (Parpola, 1986) Sidenote: "Vedic" means from the time of the Vedas, the earliest text in India, and the Vedic culture is from around 1500 to 500 BC. However, no depiction of horses on seals nor any remains of horses have been found so far before 2000 BC. They only appear after 2000 BC. Very likely there were no Aryan speakers present before 2000 BC in the Indus Valley.
  1. The language belongs to the Munda family of languages. The Munda family is spoken largely in eastern India, and related to some Southeast Asian languages. Like Aryan, the reconstructed vocabulary of early Munda does not reflect the Harappan culture. So its candidacy for being the language of the Indus Civilization is dim.
  2. The language is Dravidian. The Dravidian family of languages is spoken in Southern Indian, but Brahui is spoken in modern Pakistan. So far this is the most promising model, as in the following points:
    • There are many Dravidian influences visible in the Vedic texts. If the Aryan language gradually replaced the Dravidian, features from Dravidian would form a "substratum" in Aryan. One of these features is the appearance of retroflex consonants in Indian languages, both Indo-European and Dravidian. In contrast, retroflex consonants do not appear in any other Indo-European language, not even Iranian ones which are closest to Indic. (For more information on retroflex consonants please visit my Phonetics page).
    • Another possible indication of Dravidian in the Indus texts is from structural analysis of the texts which suggests that the language underneath is possibly agglutinative, from the fact that sign groups often have the same initial signs but different final signs. The number of these final signs range between 1 to 3. The final signs possibly represent grammatical suffixes that modify the word (represented by the initial signs). Each suffix would represent one specific modification, and the entire cluster of suffixes would therefore put the word through a series of modifications. This suffix system can be found in Dravidian, but not Indo-European. Indo-European tongues tend to change the final sounds to modify the meaning of a word (a process called inflection), but repeated addition of sounds to the end of word is extremely rare. Often many suffixes in an agglutinative language correspond to a single inflectional ending in an inflectional language.
The Dravidian model isn't just an unapplicable theory...But first we have to know what kind of writing system is the Indus script.

A count of the number of signs reveal a lot about the type of system being used. Alphabetic systems rarely have more than 40 symbols. Syllabic systems like Linear B or Cherokee typically have 40 to 100 or so symbols. The third ranges from logophonetic to logographic, running upwards of hundreds of signs (like 500 signs in Hieroglyphic Luwian, and 5000 symbols in modern Chinese).

It appears that the maximum number of Indus script symbols is 400, although there are 200 basic signs (ie signs that are not combined from others). This means that the Indus script is probably logophonetic, in that it has both signs used for their meanings, and signs used for their phonetic values.

Many signs start off as pictorial representation of a physical object, often misleadingly called pictograms. They really are should be called logograms because they represent words in the language. However, it's next to impossible to write out a word with abstract meaning pictorially. What all early writers figured out was to use a logogram not for the object or idea it was originally supposed to stand for, but for all words sounding similar to the original word for that object or idea. For example, in English to write "leave" we can use a picture of a "leaf". This is called rebus writing, and is a tremendously common pattern in all early writing systems. We could also then use the same "leaf" symbol to stand for the sound in "relief", adding another symbol in front of the "leaf" symbol in order to indicate the "re" sound. So the logogram gained a phonetic value as well.






Testing the theory

How can we take the theoretical framework so far and apply it to archaeological data?

Numerals seem to represented by vertical lines (represented by number of lines in the glyph), but they only go up to 7. Analysis reveal 4 more signs that appear in the same context as these numerals, and so they likely represent numbers higher than 7.

The fact that no vertical-line numeral sign denotes 8 very likely means the Harappan language is based 8. (For example, the Arabic numerals that we use has symbols from 0 to 9, and to write "ten" we have to combined the symbols 1 and 0, which identify our number system as based ten.)

Base 8 languages are rare in the world, but it does appear that early Dravidian is base 8, but later changed to base 10 (possibly under Indo-European influence). When translated, the count from 1 to 7 is familiar to us: "one", "two", "three", "four", "five", "six", "seven". However, above seven, the number's etymologies become non-numerical: 8 is "number", 9 is "many minus one", and 10 is "many". (Fairservis 1983)

But can we actually read (not interpret) any symbol on the seals? We should start with "pictograms", as this one:

Many scholars (Knorozov, Parpola, Mahadevan, etc) see this sign as a fish. Fish in reconstructed Proto-Dravidian is *mîn. Coincidentally, *mîn is also the word for star. On many pots from Mohenjo Daro, an Indus site, there are drawings of fish and stars together, and so affirming this linguistic association.

Going further, often the numeral six appears before the fish. Either it means 6 fish, or 6 stars. Old Tamil (a Dravidian language still spoken today) texts from just around the 1st century AD recorded the name of the Pleiades, a star cluster visible during autumn and winter just above Orion, as "Six-Stars", or aru-mîn

.Throughout the world, titles with celestial connotations are very common, and the clause Six Stars forming part or whole of a Harappan title is not unreasonable. (Parpola, 1986)

Sometimes symbols are added to the basic sign to make new signs. Of these, the one that looks like a circumflex accent placed on top of the fish is quite interesting. It is theorized to mean "roof", and in Proto-Dravidian it is *vêy/mêy. This is phonetically similar to Proto-Dravidian word for "black", *may. Together with fish, it spells out mai-m-mîn, or "black star", which in Old Tamil means the planet Saturn. In Sanskrit texts, Saturn is associate the color black. The god of death, Yama, is the presiding of this planet, and is usually depicted as riding on a dark buffalo.

But the "fish" reading isn't accepted by all scholars. William Fairservis saw it as a combination of a loom twist and a human sign, and form a honorific title pertaining to rulership (Fairservis, 1983). I, however, am more inclined to accept the fish identification.


21 comments:

  1. your post is very nice
    read also this:-
    BhagatSingh

    ReplyDelete

  2. Are you searching online terms like Home Depot Opinion Survey at www.HomeDepot.com/Opinion Home Depot holiday hours,
    home depot hours of operations, home depot near me locations? If yes and you are searching on the Internet for
    such terms then you have been placed on the right web page. Cause here in this article of mine,
    I will be telling you everything you need to know about the Home Depot Opinion Survey.

    home depot survey winners 2017

    home depot survey rules

    home depot survey page

    ReplyDelete
  3. Many people will get lot of benefits by reading this kind of informational stuff .Thank you so much for this .
    History

    ReplyDelete
  4. It is very nice article on that topic. I was looking for something like which is interesting and knowledgeable. Do you know that Agrawal Construction Company has the most amazing townships, especially best Builders In Bhopal, with the name Sagar Green Hills. It is located in the lap of nature.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thankyou for the guidance however I would like to share information for those who are looking for help & solutions in school subject like History, History sample paper for Class 12 on the Extramarks app helped me have a good preparation for the exams and acheive my desdired result. EXTRAMARKS.COM

    ReplyDelete
  6. Very informative. I love history of Vedic period and Indus valley civilization. https://vedicperiodindia.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thank you for providing free information on Ancient History of India. Here we are sharing some more information which is not included here. Click on Category wise Indian History

    ReplyDelete
  8. HACK ANY WHATSAPP ACCOUNT
    HACK ANY INSTAGRAM ACCOUNT
    HACK ANY FACEBOOK ACCOUNT
    Using SS7

    GET ALL MONEY ADDERS SOFTWARE HERE WITH PROOF

    PAYPAL MONEY ADDER
    PAYONEER MONEY ADDER
    BITCOIN MONEY ADDER

    SKRILL MONEY ADDER

    Western Union bug

    NETELLER ADDER


    DEBIT CARD LOADER

    BANK ACCOUNT LOADER

    CREDIT CARD LOADER

    CLONE CARDS

    HACK ANY GMAIL ACCOUNT
    LinkedIn email and password hacking

    SS7 SOFTWARE AVAILABLE
    Serious inquiries only

    contact me : putro9111@gmail.com
    Telegram: https://t.me/Hackord247
    Phone: +1 (912) 805-7496
    https://makemoneywithputro.wordpress.com/

    HACK N'IMPORTE QUEL COMPTE WHATSAPP

    HACKER TOUT COMPTE INSTAGRAM

    HACK N'IMPORTE QUEL COMPTE FACEBOOK

    OBTENEZ TOUS LES LOGICIELS AJOUT D'ARGENT AVEC LA PREUVE

    AJOUT D'ARGENT PAYPAL

    AJOUT D'ARGENT PAYONEER

    BITCOIN MINER BOT
    AJOUT D'ARGENT DE SKRILL
    Bug de Western Union
    NETELLER ADDER

    CHARGEUR DE CARTE DE DÉBIT

    CHARGEUR DE COMPTE BANCAIRE

    CHARGEUR DE CARTE DE CRÉDIT

    CARTES CLONE

    HACKER TOUT COMPTE GMAIL
    Piratage d'e-mails et de mots de passe LinkedIn

    LOGICIEL SS7 DISPONIBLE

    Enquêtes sérieuses uniquement

    contactez-moi: putro9111@gmail.com

    Télégramme: https://t.me/Hackord247

    Téléphone: +1 (912) 805-7496

    https://makemoneywithputro.wordpress.com/


    私に連絡してください:putro9111@gmail.com

    WHATSAPPのアカウントをハック

    インスタグラムアカウントをハックする

    Facebookアカウントをハック


    証拠のあるすべてのマネーアダーソフトウェアをここで入手する


    PAYPAL MONEY ADDER


    PAYONEER MONEY ADDER

    ビットコインマイナーボット

    SKRILL MONEY ADDER

    ウエスタンユニオンバグ

    NETELLER ADDER

    デビットカードローダー

    銀行口座ローダー

    クレジットカードローダー

    クローンカード

    Gmailアカウントをハック
    LinkedInのメールとパスワードのハッキング

    利用可能なSS7ソフトウェア

    深刻な問い合わせのみ

    私に連絡してください:putro9111@gmail.com

    電報:https://t.me/Hackord247

    電話:+1(912)805-7496

    https://makemoneywithputro.wordpress.com/






    拥有任何WHATSAPP帐户

    拥有任何INSTAGRAM帐户

    拥有任何FACEBOOK帐户


    在此处获取带有证明的所有货币添加软件


    贝宝付款

    收款人付款人

    比特币矿工机器人

    速效货币加法器

    西联汇款错误

    NETELLER ADDER

    借记卡装载器

    银行帐户装载程序

    信用卡装载机

    克隆卡

    拥有任何GMAIL帐户
    LinkedIn电子邮件和密码黑客

    提供SS7软件

    仅认真查询

    与我联系:putro9111@gmail.com

    电报:https://t.me/Hackord247

    电话:+1(912)805-7496

    https://makemoneywithputro.wordpress.com/



    Взломать любой аккаунт

    Взломать любой аккаунт INSTAGRAM

    Взломать любой аккаунт в FACEBOOK

    ПОЛУЧИТЕ ВСЕ ПРОГРАММНОЕ ОБЕСПЕЧЕНИЕ ДЕНЕГ ДОБАВЛЯЕТ СЮДА

    ПОДСЧЕТ ДЕНЕГ PAYPAL

    PAYONEER MOND ADDER

    BITCOIN MINER BOT

    SKRILL MOND ADDER

    Ошибка Western Union

    NETELLER ADDER

    ПОГРУЗЧИК ДЕБЕТНОЙ КАРТЫ

    ПОГРУЗЧИК БАНКОВСКОГО СЧЕТА

    ПОГРУЗЧИК КРЕДИТНОЙ КАРТЫ

    КЛОННЫЕ КАРТЫ

    Взломать любой аккаунт GMAIL
    LinkedIn взлом электронной почты и паролей

    ПРОГРАММНОЕ ОБЕСПЕЧЕНИЕ SS7 В НАЛИЧИИ

    Только серьезные запросы

    свяжитесь со мной: putro9111@gmail.com

    Telegram: https://t.me/Hackord247

    Телефон: +1 (912) 805-7496

    https://makemoneywithputro.wordpress.com/



    HACKEN SIE JEDES WHATSAPP-KONTO

    HACKEN SIE JEDES INSTAGRAM-KONTO

    HACK JEDES FACEBOOK-KONTO

    HIER ERHALTEN SIE ALLE GELDADDERS-SOFTWARE MIT BEWEIS

    PAYPAL GELD ADDER

    PAYONEER GELDADDER

    BITCOIN MINER BOT

    SKRILL GELDADDER

    Western Union Bug

    NETELLER ADDER

    DEBIT CARD LOADER

    BANKKONTO-LADER

    KREDITKARTENLADER

    KLONKARTEN

    HACK JEDES GMAIL-KONTO
    LinkedIn E-Mail- und Passwort-Hacking

    SS7 SOFTWARE VERFÜGBAR

    Nur ernsthafte Anfragen

    Kontaktieren Sie mich: putro9111@gmail.com

    Telegramm: https://t.me/Hackord247

    Telefon: +1 (912) 805-7496

    https://makemoneywithputro.wordpress.com/

    ReplyDelete
  9. Really very nice information about Indus valley language and script.keep it up.History Of India In Hindi

    ReplyDelete
  10. Indus Valley Civilisation, also known as 'Harappan Civilisation', was discovered as a consequence of the excavations conducted in 1920. The culture of Indus Valley Civilization manifested the growth of an ancient society which evolved and thrived during the Bronze Age in the North-West region of India and its subcontinent.
    https://www.indianetzone.com/1/indus_valley_civilization.htm

    ReplyDelete
  11. My ordor.in is an application created to assist small businesses with inventory management, outstanding/receivable management, billing, marketing, and e-commerce functions. It offers both a web app (SaaS-based) and an Android application to help businesses manage their stocks, finances, parties, promotions, and employees.

    My ordor.in has dedicated modules for creating and managing inventories, managing stores, handling payments, providing notifications, sending quotations, and generating sales reports. Additionally, it features several ‘how-to’ videos to help businesses navigate its user-interface and get work done easily. It is also available in several local Indian languages besides English, allowing regional users from several parts of the country to use them easily.

    Both the My ordor.in web app and Android app are free, and users only have to pay if they are using the advanced staff-management feature. Additionally, upgrading to its premium version lets you use the application without its logo being visible.

    The premium version of My ordor.in is priced affordably at INR 799 annually as it allows you the opportunity for personal branding. After all, who wouldn’t want to have their personal ‘Amazon’ or ‘Flipkart’ where they can sell their products directly to consumers. The premium version allows you to assign permissions to your employees or partners based on their roles. Thus based on their designation, employees can digitally manage their responsibilities and get the necessary oversight.

    However, even with a free membership, My ordor.in allows you to swiftly create your online store, customize it, and populate it with your products. You can customize pricing, add product categories, manage stocks, and generate invoices from anywhere through the application. Moreover, you gain complete real-time visibility of your stocks, payments, campaigns, and parties through its dashboard.

    Don’t have a digital team for online branding? My ordor.in is there to take care of it with its inbuilt greetings and business cards. Thus, if you offer a discount or offer at any of your stores, you can customize the branding greetings given in the application and share them with your contacts easily. Additionally, you can create your digital store in seconds and share your online catalogues with customers on Whatsapp. You can add your brand’s name and logo there for personal branding after receiving a unique online store link that takes customers directly to your virtual shop.

    ReplyDelete
  12. https://yehaiindiamerdesh.blogspot.com/search/label/history?m=1

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks for sharing wonderful information for Indus valley language and script. have got you bookmarked to look at new things you post.
    download joker123

    ReplyDelete
  14. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  15. https://yehaiindiamerdesh.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete

free counters

For IAS OUR DREAM